Do I choose Jesus or did he choose me?

Before the fifth century dawned, Christians had discussed the freedom of the human will in the context of their long-standing dispute with paganism and gnosticism. Embedded within paganism was the widespread belief in astrology, and astrology taught a doctrine of fate—that individual destiny is controlled by the planets and stars. Christian thinkers fought against this “astral determinism” by stressing God-given human dignity and freedom. Humans are responsible before God for their own choices and destinies; these are not forced on us by the despotism of fate or the power of the stars. There was a similar issue with gnosticism. A strong vein of gnostic teaching held that only a special class of humans, the “pneumatics” (spiritual ones), had it within them to be saved. The rest of humanity, and even the pneumatics before their gnostic illumination, were compelled to sin by their fleshly natures, despite their rational wills. Gnostics considered matter the wellspring of all evil; fu...