Posts

Showing posts with the label DICK HARFIELD

Dick Harfield NO EXODUS VS Chat Gpt MINOR EXODUS

Image
What is the scholarly consensus on the historicity of the Exodus story in the Bible? What percentage of scholars believe there is a historical basis for the Exodus? Dick Harfield Lives in Sydney, Australia 7y There is a quite strong consensus among historians that there was never an Exodus from Egypt as portrayed in the Bible. Israel Finkelstein puts the figure at about 95 per cent of modern historians. F. S. Frick says, in ‘Israel as a tribal society’, published in The World of Ancient Israel: Sociological, Anthropological and Political Perspectives (edited by R. E. Clements): The assumptions regarding the origins of the Hebrews can be defined by ‘immigration’, ‘revolt’ or ‘emergence’. It is towards a concept of ‘emergence’ that most recent scholarship about Israel's origins has been moving. Studies on Israel's origins tend to suggest ‘emergence’ or ‘evolution’ as the descriptions of the process whereby Israel made its appearance in Palestine. The ‘immigration’ model has been...

Dick Harfield (aethist) gets it wrong again

Image
This is someone's question: In the book of Job, which begins with Satan and the sons of Elohim meeting with Yahweh, we have the story of the great sea monster scaring God. Is this an example of traces of henotheism in the Bible? This is Harfield's answer : In Job 41:25, “the gods” are afraid. The Hebrew word used here is elim, a plural form of el, which translates to ‘gods’, but which is commonly translated into English as ‘the mighty’ in order to preserve biblical monotheism. Translated literally, it is evidence of early Jewish henotheism. The leviathan (Job 41:1) was a multi-headed chaos monster mentioned in other Ancient Near Eastern religions. God had to defeat the leviathan in order to continue with creation. In this context, ‘mighty’ — if this is intended to refer to mighty humans — makes no sense if they have not even yet been created, but other henotheistic gods do. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ This is my answer:   This...

Atheist Dick Harfield on Paul's encounter with jesus

Image
  A PERSON'S QUESTION: What happened to the people who were in Paul’s entourage? Did they also see Jesus, and did any of them go blind, or was Paul travelling alone on the Damascus Road? HARFIELD'S ANSWER: The author of Acts saw no reason to maintain consistency across the three accounts of Paul’s conversion on the road to Damascus so, although substantially similar, there are some interesting differences. In each account in Acts, there was a blinding light: Paul saw the light in in the version at Acts 9:3-8, but Paul’s men did not. The whole entourage heard Jesus’ voice. At Acts 22:6-11, Paul’s men saw the light but did not hear Jesus’ voice. Paul’s men probably saw the light at Acts 26:13-19, as they fell down; we are not told if they heard Jesus’ voice. In the account of Paul's conversion, Jesus is supposed to have remarked to Paul as he lay on the ground, "It hurts you to kick against the goad [or 'pricks']" (Acts 9:5, 26:14). This should give a good...

Responding to Dick Harfield on Matthew 2:23

Image
QUESTION TO DICK HARFIELD: Who is the prophet referred to in Matthew? DICK HARFIELD'S RESPONSE: Matthew 2:23 refers to a prophet whose identity has long puzzled scholars because there is nothing in the Old Testament or even the Apocrypha that mentions a Nazarene. One popular suggestion is from Judges 13:5, where it says of Samson, "the child shall be a Nazirite." However, Matthew does not say ‘Nazirite ’, and the word has no known link to the town of Nazareth; moreover, Jesus was not a Nazirite and is never described as one. Some believe Isaiah 60:21-22 was the prophecy of which Matthew wrote, because the Hebrew for a small twig is netzer — presumably close enough to be a prophecy that Jesus would be called a Nazarene, but not very plausible. I believe the real reason is closer to home, as you can read in The Mystery of the Nazarenes. We now know that Matthew’s Gospel was substantially based on Mark’s Gospel, the Greek manuscripts of which always refer to Jesus the Nazar...

Dick Harfield does it again

Image
Who authored Titus, 1 Timothy and 2 Timothy? Dick Harfield goes to great lengths to say it was not the Apostle Paul, based on Marcion's gathered letters.  Paul authored all three letters—1 Timothy and Titus after his release from his first Roman imprisonment (around A.D. 62–64), and 2 Timothy during his second Roman imprisonment (around A.D. 66–67), shortly before his death.1 These letters were directed to his apostolic representatives Timothy and Titus, who were overseeing churches in Ephesus and Crete respectively, and Paul provided them with guidance on managing those congregations.1 The authorship question has generated significant scholarly debate. While external evidence supports Pauline authorship, some modern commentators have questioned whether Paul wrote these letters.2 Critical scholars have challenged Pauline authorship, proposing instead that a second-century follower of Paul composed all three epistles.1  However, early Church Fathers—including Ignatius, Polycarp...

Dick Harfield's over statement on Mary and Joseph

Image
  This is Dick Harfield's answer to the question:  Why did Mary and Joseph have to go to Bethlehem for the census? Luke’s Gospel said that Joseph had to go to Bethlehem for the census of Quirinius “because he was of the house and lineage of David”. There would have been no reason for Mary to go there, as women were not counted in censuses. The reason for Joseph going to Bethlehem is unclear, since the census was applied only to establish to expected taxes from the newly acquired Roman province of Judea; as a resident of Galilee, Joseph would not have been assessed for taxes in what was effectively a foreign country. Uta Ranke-Heinemann says, in Putting Away Childish Things : There would have been no such journey unless Joseph had owned property in Bethlehem. If he had no real estate, as an inhabitant of Galilee under the tetrarch Herod Antipas, he would not have been affected by the order of the Syrian governor Quirinius. Joseph owned no property in Bethlehem. In that case he ...