How old is human rock art?

An Australian-led team has dated cave art in Sulawesi at about 40,000 years old, putting it in the same vintage as the oldest known paintings in Spain and France.

The images are spread across more than 90 sites in a limestone area 45 minutes’ drive from Makassar, Indonesia’s fifth-largest city. Archeologists have known of them for more than 50 years but assumed them to be less than 10,000 years old.

Griffith University geochemist Maxime Aubert said he had first visited the site briefly, taking samples from a few caves. “I ran them in the machine and when I saw the numbers coming out, I thought, ‘Oh shit’,” he said.

The study, dates the earliest image — a hand stencil — as at least 39,900 years old. The world’s oldest known cave painting, a red disc in Spain, is dated at 900 years older.

The Sulawesi sites also include images of pig-like animals painted more than 35,400 years ago, possibly making them older than the earliest known figurative rock art in Western Europe — a painted rhinoceros in the Chauvet Cave in France, estimated at between 35,300 and 38,800 years old.

Dr Aubert’s team obtained dates by measuring the ratio of radioactive isotopes in stalactite-like growths on top of the Sulawesi paintings, making them minimum estimates. Many European measurements were ­obtained through radiocarbon dating of charcoal, making them maximum estimates. “You’re not dating when the painting was done, you’re dating when the tree (that provided the charcoal) stopped growing,” he said.

He said the oldest known rock art in northern Australia was painted about 28,000 years ago, but technological advances could yield older findings. Most Australian rock art was in sandstone country, which was hard to date.

Excavations in Arnhem Land have found ochre crayons in 50,000-year-old deposits. “But we can’t prove (they were) used to make paintings,” Dr Aubert said.

He said the abundant rock art in Europe had convinced anthropologists that the human capacity for abstract thinking originated there. “That led people to believe humans became modern in ­Europe,” he said. “Now we know it’s not true.”

DATING AUSTRALIAN ROCK ARTAustralia is blessed with many beautiful examples of Aboriginal cave paintings and engravings but what does science tell us about how old they are? What are the different methods used to date such artworks? And what are some the challenges involved in dating them?

Many people will be forgiven for thinking that Australia has some of the oldest rock art in the world, but the truth there is no reliable dating to show this.

"You often hear people talk about the oldest continuous culture in the world being Aboriginal culture," says geologist Professor Brad Pillans of the Australian National University.

"Many archaeologists have thought rock art has been a part of Aboriginal culture since earliest times... but it's an inference."

Pillans and colleague Keith Fifield have argued that rocks bearing Aboriginal engravings on the Burrup Peninsulahave the potential to preserve the engravings for 50,000 to 60,000 years, but they have done no direct dating of the engravings themselves.

According to archaeologist Dr Bruno David of Monash University the oldest reliably-dated rock engravings in Australia are 13,000 to 15000 years old, and are in Laura, Queensland.

"These were dated using radiocarbon dating of charcoal buried at the same depth of engravings," he says.

Beyond engravings, the oldest reliably-dated rock art in Australia is 28,000 years old. It's a fragment of a charcoal cave painting found buried in an Arnhem Land cave by David and colleagues.

The fragment was both preserved and dateable by being buried in carbon-containing soil

But dating most rock art isn't usually quite so straightforward.


Challenges of dating

"Rock art is notoriously difficult to date," says David. "Most pigment art contains no dateable carbon, and therefore radiocarbon dating is usually not feasible."

What is known as the oldest rock art in the world - cave paintings in Indonesia and Spain — was dated using a more complex method that measures the age of a microscopic layer of minerals deposited after the art is created. "It's like a laminate," says David.

Instead of measuring the decay of radioactive carbon, this method relies on measuring the decay of uranium in the microscopic layer to provide a minimum age for the art. In some cases a similar layer beneath the art gives a maximum age for the art.

In both Spain and Indonesia, the cave art appeared in deep limestone caves.

Not only did this protect the artwork from the elements, but it also provided a good environment for the production of these dateable layers.

"Australia doesn't have much art in deep limestone caves," says David.


Ochre on sandstone

Indeed, he says, the richest collections of rock art in the Kimberley, Arnhem Land, Cape York Peninsula, are on sandstone.

Take the ochre painting of a giant emu-like bird found on the Arnhem Land plateau, which some believe could be 40,000 years old — as old as the paintings in Spain and Indonesia.

There is no dateable carbon from plants, charcoal or dust caught in the ochre pigment, says David.

And it's difficult to use a similar approach to that used on the limestone art so new methods need to be developed.

"It's very likely that there is something extremely old in Australia but it's just very hard to date," says David. "And there are very few people doing research on rock art." David says there are hand stencils in some limestone caves in North Queensland that are believed to be more than 30,000 years old, and he hopes to be involved in dating these in the future.


Circumstantial evidence

The bottom line, says David, is that very little rock art anywhere in the world has been dated, including in Australia.

But there remain a lot of hints and circumstantial evidence around to support the idea that Australia is in fact home to the world's oldest art.

Pillans, who studies the Burrup rock engravings, describes the giant bird painting on the Arnhem Land plateau as a "hint of older rock art".

Some researchers say the creature looks like Genyornis which is believed to have gone extinct at least 40,000 years ago.

"The people who drew that animal could only have seen it more than 40,000 years ago," says Pillans.

David emphasises it is still uncertain whether the bird is actually a Genyornis and points instead to ochre crayons that date to around 50,000 years ago.

"We don't have the [dated] art itself, but we've found the tools that were used to make the art. For that reason, we rightfully assume that Australia has pigment art going back to when people first came here which is close to 50,000 years ago."

Professor Brad Pillans and Dr Bruno David were interviewed by Anna Salleh

Related articles

• Ancient Indonesian Find May Rival Oldest Known Cave Art (rss.nytimes.com)
• Prehistoric Paintings in Indonesia May Be Oldest Cave Art Ever (news.yahoo.com)
• Prehistoric Paintings in Indonesia May Be Oldest Cave Art Ever (ca.news.yahoo.com)
• Prehistoric Indonesian paintings may be oldest cave art (mnn.com)
• Indonesian Cave Paintings As Old As Europe's Ancient Art (wnyc.org)
• Cave Paintings in Indonesia Redraw Picture of Earliest Art (news.nationalgeographic.com)
• Prehistoric Paintings in Indonesia May Be Oldest Cave Art Ever (livescience.com)
• World's oldest hand stencil found in Indonesian cave (newscientist.com)
• Cave paintings in Indonesia suggest art came out of Africa - The Guardian (theguardian.com)
• Ancient Indonesian cave paintings rewrite history of human art (trust.org)