Many call themselves churches but what makes a church?
 |
| St. Peter's Basilica at Early Morning (Photo credit: Wikipedia) |
saying, ‘This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you
drink it, in remembrance of me’” (v. 25).
There are many different bodies that call themselves churches, whether or not they are true manifestations of the church of Jesus Christ. How then can we tell when a church in name is also a church in reality?
Faced with this same problem, the Reformers and Roman Catholics answered this question very differently. Rome has said that the bishop is the mark of the church, that is, the true church is present when you have a duly consecrated bishop who is part of a line of succession going back to the apostles. Ultimately, a bishop is a true bishop only if he submits to the pope; thus, in Roman Catholicism only Roman Catholic parishes constitute the true church.
Protestants recognize the biblical failings of this view and, in studying
Scripture, traditionally define a true church according to two criteria:
1. The Word — there is no true church without the right proclamation of the
Word of God. In other words, a group that denies any of the essential truths
of the Christian faith is not a church. The essential truths of Christianity
are clearly taught in Scripture, and the Nicene Creed is one document that
helpfully summarizes them. A truth like justification by faith alone is
included in this list even though it is not specifically mentioned in the
creed, because Paul lists it as a defining mark of the Gospel (Gal. 1:6–9;
2:15–16), and it is a necessary deduction from the creed’s emphasis on
salvation through Christ alone.
2. The Sacraments — a true church rightly celebrates the Lord’s Supper and
baptism. That is, the sacraments must be conducted in line with Scripture’s
clear teaching, and we must allow for latitude where such things are not so
plain. For example, the biblical instruction on the mode of baptism is not as
clear as we might like; thus, we cannot anathematize those who disagree with
us in this specific area. Celebrating the sacraments correctly also involves
keeping unrepentant sinners from partaking in these means of grace (church
discipline). Though inseparably linked to the sacraments, sometimes we make
special mention of church discipline as the third mark of the church (1 Cor.
5).
First Corinthians 11:17–34 gives us the marks of the church specifically and
through good and necessary deduction. The whole passage concerns the Lord’s
Supper, a reference to the sacraments. Paul also gives the words of
institution, a reference to the Word of God since these words were first
spoken by Jesus. How highly do you value these means of grace and marks of the church? They are necessary for your spiritual growth and maturity.
