What was the purpose of this man being born blind?
 |
| The Miracle of Christ Healing the Blind by El Greco, c. 1570 (Photo credit: Wikipedia) |
Who sinned, this man or his parents, that he should be born blind?—John 9:2
Their dilemma was based upon a wrong assumption they had been taught all their lives, namely, that illness is a sign of God’s judgment. There was no question in their minds that someone had sinned. But who?
The disciples were trying from their limited perspective to answer a question we often find ourselves asking. It is the why question. Why did this happen? Why did my son run away? Why did my father contract cancer? Why did our house burn? Why did I lose my job? Why was I sued?
The questions are endless. Each of us has a specific list. Sometimes there is so much emotion involved we dare not even allow ourselves to verbalize the frustration we feel because asking for and finding no clear–cut answer threaten the foundation of all we believe about God and His goodness. And yet, the questions still linger.
Like the disciples, we are prone to view adversity narrowly. We turn on ourselves and begin an often fruitless journey into our recent—and sometimes not–so–recent—past. Our purpose is to find the reason for the adversity we face. The thought may arise: Surely this is God’s way of paying me back. If, however, we are convinced that nothing we have done merits the magnitude of our adversity, we have no choice, it seems, but to question the goodness and faithfulness of God.
In His response to the disciples’ question, Jesus revealed yet another error that plagued the theology of the day. But His answer did much more than that. It enlightens us and offers a much broader perspective on suffering than that held by many. His answer brings hope to those who have thus far been afraid to ask why. It allows us to look beyond ourselves—and that is always an improvement!
Jesus answered, “It was neither that this man sinned, nor his parents.” In others words, “Your thinking is too narrow. You need some new categories.” I believe many well–meaning Christians need some new categories when it comes to the subject of adversity. Thinking too narrowly on this subject sets one up for needless guilt. And as in the case of Jesus’ disciples, it warps one’s perspective on the suffering of others.
Jesus said, It was neither that this man sinned, nor his parents; but it was in order that the works of God might be displayed in him.—John 9:3
The implications of that statement are staggering. The phrase “in order that” denotes purpose. There was a purpose to this man’s blindness. The disciples saw his blindness as the result of something. In fact, they saw all illness in terms of result. Jesus, however, let it be known in no uncertain terms that this blindness was not the result of something the man did. This man’s blindness was a part of God’s purpose. In other words, this man’s blindness was from God. That was a difficult sentence to write—much less believe.
Is it possible that adversity can originate with God? All of us would be more comfortable if Jesus had said, “This man is blind because he sinned, but God is going to use it anyway.” That would be a much easier pill to swallow. But Jesus leaves us no escape. Sin was not the direct cause of this man’s blindness; God was.
Stanley, C. F. (1989). How to handle adversity. Nashville: Oliver-Nelson.
